Cuts in 401k Matches are Being Reinstated

Employer matching funds have been the target of corporate cost-cutting for more than a year now. Looking to preserve cash and slash personnel costs hundreds of companies – big and small – have reduced or suspended their 401k matches. In recession, the allure to cut 401k matches is strong: 401k cuts typically equate to 2 percent or 3 percent of payroll and can be swiftly implemented.

But as the recession eases, there are strong indications of a slowdown in 401k cuts. The Pension Rights Center maintains an unofficial list of employers that have changed or suspended 401k matches. A plot of the announcements listed on their website shows a sharp fall off from levels of early 2009.

In the same vein, two recent studies (By Fidelity and Watson Wyatt) note that many companies that reduced or suspended matches now indicate they plan to reinstate them in coming months:

According to Fidelity:

Fidelity also said companies which lowered or suspended their 401(k) match in the past year are starting to reinstate the match.

The company said a survey of plan sponsors shows 27 percent of employers said they had already reinstated the match or plan to reinstate it within the next 12 months. The trend is particularly true with larger plans of 5,000 participants or more, with 44 percent of those employers indicating they have either already reinstated or plan to reinstate their match over the next year.
According to Wyatt:

In the next six months, 35% of firms that snipped away at their matching programs are planning to bulk them up again, according to a recent Watson Wyatt survey. That’s up from 24% two months ago.

The return of the 401k match is, of course, great news. Matches are easily the best incentive for employees to make (or increase) their own contributions. When employers cut matches, worker contributions invariably fall off. Hopefully, the damage done by the recent round of 401k cuts can be quickly undone.